The improvement effect of 11 kinds of exercise protocols on elderly patients with sarcopenia：a network Meta analysis

doi:10.3761/j.issn.0254-1769.2022.21.015

Abstract

Abstract:

Objective To evaluate the effect of 11 kinds of exercise training on the improvement of physical function，muscle strength，and muscle mass in elderly patients with sarcopenia by network Meta-analysis. Methods A systematic search of Web of Science，PubMed，Embase，Cochrane Library，CINAHL，CNKI，Chinese Biomedical Literature Database（CBM），WanFang and VIP was carried out to identify randomized control trials about the effect of exercise training on the improvement of elderly patients with sarcopenia from inception to January 2022. The network meta-analysis was performed by Stata 15.0 software. Results A total of 34 pieces of research involving 2 199 patients and 11 exercise training were included. The results of network meta-analysis indicated that resistance training，Baduanjin，whole body vibration training，group comprehensive training，and home comprehensive training could improve the physical function of elderly patients with sarcopenia compared with non-exercise controls（P<0.05）;resistance training and kettlebell training could significantly improve the grip strength of elderly patients with sarcopenia （P<0.05）;resistance training could improve the skeletal muscle index of elderly patients with sarcopenia （P<0.05）. Conclusion This study showed that resistance training is currently the best exercise intervention in elderly patients with sarcopenia，followed by group comprehensive training and whole body vibration training. However，more studies are still needed to further demonstrate.

Key words: Senile Sarcopenia, Exercise, Physical Function, Muscle Mass, Muscle Strength, Nursing Care

摘要：

目的通过网状Meta分析评价11种运动训练对老年肌少症患者身体功能、肌肉力量和肌肉质量改善效果的影响。方法检索Web of Science、PubMed、Embase、Cochrane Library、CINAHL、中国知网、中国生物医学文献数据库、万方数据库和维普数据库中关于运动训练对老年肌少症患者身体功能、肌肉力量和肌肉质量改善效果的随机对照试验。检索时限为建库至2022年1月。采用Stata 15.0软件进行网状Meta分析。结果纳入34项研究，共2 199例患者。网状Meta分析结果表明，与非运动对照组相比，阻力训练、小组综合训练、八段锦、全身振动训练、家庭综合训练可改善老年肌少症患者的身体功能（P<0.05）;阻力训练和壶铃训练可改善老年肌少症患者的握力（P<0.05）;阻力训练可改善老年肌少症患者的骨骼肌指数（P<0.05）。结论在改善老年肌少症患者身体功能、肌肉力量和质量方面，阻力训练是目前最优的运动干预措施，其次为小组综合训练和全身振动训练，但仍需更多研究进一步论证。

关键词: 老年肌肉减少症, 运动, 身体功能, 肌肉质量, 肌肉力量, 护理

WANG Lili, TIAN Liya, NIU Qi, LIU Weihua. The improvement effect of 11 kinds of exercise protocols on elderly patients with sarcopenia：a network Meta analysis[J]. Chinese Journal of Nursing, 2022, 57(21): 2652-2660.

王丽丽, 田丽雅, 牛琪, 柳韦华. 11种运动对老年肌少症患者身体功能改善效果的网状Meta分析[J]. 中华护理杂志, 2022, 57(21): 2652-2660.

Figures/Tables 3

References 52

[1]	Papadopoulou SK. Sarcopenia:a contemporary health problem among older adult populations[J]. Nutrients, 2020, 12(5):1293. DOI URL
[2]	Han PP, Kang L, Guo Q, et al. Prevalence and factors associated with sarcopenia in suburb-dwelling older Chinese using the Asian working group for sarcopenia definition[J]. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci, 2015, 71(4):529-535. DOI URL
[3]	余姜璇, 单雪琪, 王俊杰, 等. 老年肌少症患者营养管理的最佳证据总结[J]. 中华护理杂志, 2022, 57(18):2261-2267.
	Yu JX, Shan XQ, Wang JJ, et al. Best evidence summary for nutrition management in elderly patients with sarcopenia[J]. ChinJ of Nurs, 2022, 57(18):2261-2267.
[4]	沈睿, 王茜茜, 徐霓影, 等. 老年肌少症患者运动干预的最佳证据总结[J]. 中华护理杂志, 2021, 56(10):1560-1566. DOI
	Shen R, Wang XX, Xu NY, et al. Evidence summary of exercise intervention for elderly patients with sarcopenia[J]. Chin J Nurs, 2021, 56(10):1560-1566. DOI
[5]	王坤, 罗炯, 刘立, 等. 老年人肌少症的成因、评估及应对[J]. 中国组织工程研究, 2019, 23(11):1767-1773.
	Wang K, Luo J, Liu L, et al. Causes,assessment and treatment strategies of sarcopenia in older adults[J]. Chin J Tissue Eng Res, 2019, 23(11):1767-1773.
[6]	Chang KV, Chen JD, Wu WT, et al. Is sarcopenia associated with hepatic encephalopathy in liver cirrhosis? A systematic review and meta-analysis[J]. J Formos Med Assoc, 2019, 118(4):833-842. DOI URL
[7]	Higgins J, Green S, Higgins J,. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions,version 5.1.0. the cochrane collaboration[R]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011.
[8]	Kim HK, Suzuki T, Saito K, et al. Effects of exercise and amino acid supplementation on body composition and physical function in community-dwelling elderly Japanese sarcopenic wom-en:a randomized controlled trial[J]. J Am Geriatr Soc, 2012, 60(1):16-23. DOI URL
[9]	Shahar S, Kamaruddin NS, Badrasawi M, et al. Effectiveness of exercise and protein supplementation intervention on body composition,functional fitness,and oxidative stress among el-derly Malays with sarcopenia[J]. Clin Interv Aging, 2013, 8:1365-1375.
[10]	Hassan BH, Hewitt J, Keogh JW, et al. Impact of resistance training on sarcopenia in nursing care facilities:a pilot study[J]. Geriatr Nurs, 2016, 37(2):116-121. DOI URL
[11]	Maruya K, Asakawa Y, Ishibashi H, et al. Effect of a simple and adherent home exercise program on the physical function of community dwelling adults sixty years of age and older with pre-sarcopenia or sarcopenia[J]. J Phys Ther Sci, 2016, 28(11):3183-3188. PMID
[12]	Kim H, Suzuki T, Saito K, et al. Effects of exercise and tea- catechins on muscle mass,strength and walking ability in community-dwelling elderly Japanese sarcopenic women:a randomized controlled trial[J]. Geriatr Gerontol Int, 2013, 13(2):458-465. DOI URL
[13]	Wei N, Pang MY, Ng SS, et al. Optimal frequency/time combination of whole body vibration training for developing physical performance of people with sarcopenia:a randomized controlled trial[J]. Clin Rehabil, 2017, 31(10):1313-1321. DOI URL
[14]	Mafi F, Biglari S, Ghardashi Afousi A, et al. Improvement in skeletal muscle strength and plasma levels of follistatin and myostatin induced by an 8-week resistance training and epicatechin supplementation in sarcopenic older adults[J]. J Aging Phys Act, 2019, 27(3):384-391.
[15]	Chen HT, Wu HJ, Chen YJ, et al. Effects of 8-week kettlebell training on body composition,muscle strength,pulmonary func-tion,and chronic low-grade inflammation in elderly women with sarcopenia[J]. Exp Gerontol, 2018, 112:112-118. DOI URL
[16]	Zhu LY, Chan R, Kwok T, et al. Effects of exercise and nutrition supplementation in community-dwelling older Chinese people with sarcopenia:a randomized controlled trial[J]. Age Ageing, 2019, 48(2):220-228. DOI URL
[17]	Tsekoura M, Billis E, Tsepis E, et al. The effects of group and home-based exercise programs in elderly with sarcopenia:a randomized controlled trial[J]. J Clin Med, 2018, 7(12):E480.
[18]	Vikberg S, Sörlén N, Brandén L, et al. Effects of resistance train-ing on functional strength and muscle mass in 70-year-old individuals with pre-sarcopenia:a randomized controlled trial[J]. J Am Med Dir Assoc, 2019, 20(1):28-34. DOI PMID
[19]	Yamada M, Kimura Y, Ishiyama D, et al. Synergistic effect of bodyweight resistance exercise and protein supplementation on skeletal muscle in sarcopenic or dynapenic older adults[J]. Geriatr Gerontol Int, 2019, 19(5):429-437. DOI PMID
[20]	Zhu YQ, Peng N, Zhou M, et al. Tai Chi and whole-body vibrating therapy in sarcopenic men in advanced old age:a clinical randomized controlled trial[J]. Eur J Ageing, 2019, 16(3):273-282. DOI URL
[21]	Makizako H, Nakai Y, Tomioka K, et al. Effects of a multicomponent exercise program in physical function and muscle mass in sarcopenic/pre-sarcopenic adults[J]. J Clin Med, 2020, 9(5):E1386.
[22]	Wang R, Liang Y, Jiang J, et al. Effectiveness of a short-term mixed exercise program for treating sarcopenia in hospitalized patients aged 80 years and older:a prospective clinical trial[J]. J Nutr Health Aging, 2020, 24(10):1087-1093. DOI PMID
[23]	Liang YX, Wang RJ, Jiang JJ, et al. A randomized controlled trial of resistance and balance exercise for sarcopenic patients aged 80-99 years[J]. Sci Rep, 2020, 10(1):18756. DOI URL
[24]	Osuka Y, Kojima N, Sasai H, et al. Effects of exercise and/or β-hydroxy-β-methylbutyrate supplementation on muscle mass,muscle strength,and physical performance in older women with low muscle mass:a randomized,double-blind,placebo-controlled trial[J]. Am J Clin Nutr, 2021, 114(4):1371-1385. DOI URL
[25]	Seo MW, Jung SW, Kim SW, et al. Effects of 16 weeks of resistance training on muscle quality and muscle growth factors in older adult women with sarcopenia:a randomized con-trolled trial[J]. Int J Environ Res Public Health, 2021, 18(13):6762. DOI URL
[26]	Sen EI, Eyigor S, Dikici Yagli M, et al. Effect of home-based exercise program on physical function and balance in older adults with sarcopenia:a multicenter randomized controlled study[J]. J Aging Phys Act, 2021, 29(6):1010-1017.
[27]	Lee YH, Lee PH, Lin LF, et al. Effects of progressive elastic band resistance exercise for aged osteosarcopenic adiposity women[J]. Exp Gerontol, 2021, 147:111272. DOI URL
[28]	Jung WS, Kim YY, Park HY. Circuit training improvements in Korean women with sarcopenia[J]. Percept Mot Skills, 2019, 126(5):828-842. DOI URL
[29]	Liao CD, Tsauo JY, Lin LF, et al. Effects of elastic resistance exercise on body composition and physical capacity in older women with sarcopenic obesity:a CONSORT-compliant pros-pective randomized controlled trial[J]. Medicine (Baltimore), 2017, 96(23):e7115. DOI URL
[30]	Cebrià I Iranzo Mà, Balasch-Bernat M, Tortosa-Chuliá Má et al. Effects of resistance training of peripheral muscles versus respiratory muscles in older adults with sarcopenia who are institutionalized:a randomized controlled trial[J]. J Aging Phys Act, 2018, 26(4):637-646.
[31]	Li Z, Cui M, Yu K, et al. Effects of nutrition supplementation and physical exercise on muscle mass,muscle strength and fat mass among sarcopenic elderly:a randomized controlled trial[J]. Physiol Appliquee Nutr Metab, 2021, 46(5):494-500.
[32]	王宾, 马士荣, 胡莺. 健身气功易筋经锻炼对骨骼肌减少症患者康复效果的影响[J]. 中国老年学杂志, 2016, 36(4):898-899.
	Wang B, Ma SR, Hu Y. Influence of Qigong yijinjing exercise on the rehabilitation effect of patients with skeletal muscle reduction[J]. Chin J Gerontol, 2016, 36(4):898-899.
[33]	朱高峰, 罗开涛, 沈志方, 等. 导引功法易筋经对老年骨骼肌减少症平衡功能的影响[J]. 浙江中医杂志, 2018, 53(5):351-352.
	Zhu GF, Luo KT, Shen ZF, et al. Effect of Chinese medicine guidance Gong fa yijinjing on balance function of senile patients with sarcopenia[J]. Zhejiang J Tradit Chin Med, 2018, 53(5):351-352.
[34]	刘燕, 蔡俊. 弹力带处方式训练对老年肌少症患者下肢肌力与功能性运动能力的影响[J]. 长春师范大学学报, 2020, 39(10):123-126.
	Liu Y, Cai J. Effect of elastic belt style training on lower limb muscle strength and functional exercise ability of elde-rly patients with sarcopenia[J]. J Chang Norm Univ, 2020, 39(10):123-126.
[35]	邵伟华, 高丽霞, 王素星, 等. 维生素D联合阻抗训练对老年肌少症患者骨骼肌质量、日常生活活动能力及血清学指标的影响[J]. 中华老年多器官疾病杂志, 2020, 19(9):656-660.
	Shao WH, Gao LX, Wang SX, et al. Effects of vitamin D combined with resistance training on skeletal muscle mass,activities of daily living and serological indices in elderly patients with sarcopenia[J]. Chin J Mult Organ Dis Elder, 2020, 19(9):656-660.
[36]	周苏坡, 邹颖, 孙小斐, 等. 八段锦预防老年肌少症人群跌倒的研究[J]. 体育科技, 2020, 41(6):27-28,30.
	Zhou SP, Zou Y, Sun XF, et al. Research on Baduanjin for preventing falls in elderly patients with sarcopenia[J]. Sport Sci and Tech, 2020, 41(6):27-28,30.
[37]	董欣, 莫懿晗, 王秀华, 等. 抗阻运动对老年肌少症危险人群肌肉量、肌力和活动能力的影响[J]. 中国护理管理, 2021, 21(8):1190-1195.
	Dong X, Mo YH, Wang XH, et al. Effects of resistance exercise on muscle mass,muscle strength and physical performa-nce in the elderly at risk of sarcopenia[J]. Chin Nurs Manag, 2021, 21(8):1190-1195.
[38]	王光辉, 蔡文玮, 沈晓君, 等. 弹力带抗阻运动训练12周对社区老年肌少症患者肌力的影响[J]. 中国临床保健杂志, 2021, 24(6):800-804.
	Wang GH, Cai WW, Shen XJ, et al. Effects of resistance train-ing using elastic band for 12 weeks on muscle strength of elderly patients with sarcopenia in community[J]. Chin J Clin Healthc, 2021, 24(6):800-804.
[39]	陈娟, 侯晓俊, 冯文化, 等. 家庭远程锻炼指导在社区老年肌少症危险人群中的应用效果[J]. 中国民康医学, 2022, 34(1):163-165,169.
	Chen J, Hou XJ, Feng WH, et al. Application effects of family remote exercise guidance in community elderly people with sarcopenia risk[J]. Med J Chin People’s Health, 2022, 34(1):163-165,169.
[40]	陈娟, 冯文化, 侯晓俊, 等. 壶铃训练对老年女性肌肉减少症患者的影响[J]. 国际医药卫生导报, 2022(2):180-184.
	Chen J, Feng WH, Hou XJ, et al. Effect of kettlebell training on elderly women with sarcopenia[J]. Int Med Health Guid News, 2022(2):180-184.
[41]	王丽珍, 郭颖彬, 骆俊宏. 居家运动训练对老年肥胖型肌少症的效果[J]. 中国康复理论与实践, 2019, 25(1):90-96.
	Wang LZ, Guo YB, Luo JH. Effects of home exercise on sarcopenia obesity for aging people[J]. Chin J Rehabil Theory Rract, 2019, 25(1):90-96.
[42]	陈管洁, 张海林, 尹丽霞, 等. 维持性血液透析合并肌少症患者运动干预方案的构建及应用[J]. 中华护理杂志, 2022, 57(7):798-806. DOI
	Chen GJ, Zhang HL, Yin LX, et al. Construction and application of intradialytic exercise intervention program in maintenance hemodialysis patients with sarcopenia[J]. Chin J Nurs, 2022, 57(7):798-806. DOI
[43]	Lu LQ, Mao L, Feng YW, et al. Effects of different exercise training modes on muscle strength and physical performance in older people with sarcopenia:a systematic review and meta-analysis[J]. BMC Geriatr, 2021, 21(1):708. DOI URL
[44]	于卫华, 王莉, 徐忠梅. 社区老年人常速行走步态特征与跌倒的相关性研究[J]. 中华护理杂志, 2017, 52(1):44-48.
	Yu WH, Wang L, Xu ZM. The relationship between gait features at usual speed and falls among community-dwelling elderly people[J]. Chin J Nurs, 2017, 52(1):44-48.
[45]	Zhang YX, Zhang YQ, Du SZ, et al. Exercise interventions for improving physical function,daily living activities and quality of life in community-dwelling frail older adults:a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials[J]. Geriatr Nurs, 2020, 41(3):261-273. DOI URL
[46]	Komatsu H, Yagasaki K, Saito Y, et al. Regular group exercise contributes to balanced health in older adults in Japan:a qualitative study[J]. BMC Geriatr, 2017, 17(1):190. DOI PMID
[47]	荣湘江, 梁丹丹, 钱京京. 太极拳对中老年人握力及反应时的影响[J]. 中国康复医学杂志, 2010, 25(4):343-345.
	Rong XJ, Liang DD, Qian JJ. The effects of taijiquan on the grip strength and reacting time of middle aged and aged people[J]. Chin J Rehabil Med, 2010, 25(4):343-345.
[48]	Vancini RL, Andrade MS, Rufo-Tavares W, et al. Kettlebell ex-ercise as an alternative to improve aerobic power and muscle strength[J]. J Hum Kinet, 2019, 66:5-6. DOI URL
[49]	Brotto M, Abreu EL. Sarcopenia:pharmacology of today and tomorrow[J]. J Pharmacol Exp Ther, 2012, 343(3):540-546. DOI PMID
[50]	温鹏天, 张瑞丽, 胡文清, 等. 不同运动干预方式对老年人肌少症改善效果的Meta分析[J]. 中国康复理论与实践, 2021, 27(11):1291-1298.
	Wen PT, Zhang RL, Hu WQ, et al. Effect of different modes of exercise on sarcopenia in older adults:a meta-analysis[J]. Chin J Rehabil Theory Pract, 2021, 27(11):1291-1298.
[51]	Vlietstra L, Hendrickx W, Waters DL. Exercise interventions in healthy older adults with sarcopenia:a systematic review and meta-analysis[J]. Australas J Ageing, 2018, 37(3):169-183. DOI PMID
[52]	颜航, 镇雪婷, 黄青青, 等. 全身振动训练对老年人平衡能力效果的Meta分析[J]. 中华护理杂志, 2020, 55(2):243-249. DOI
	Yan H, Zhen XT, Huang QQ, et al. Effectiveness of whole-body vibration training on balance ability of the elderly:a meta-analysis[J]. Chin J Nurs, 2020, 55(2):243-249. DOI